Looking for the #1 favorite spot on the island and a popular choice amongst visitors and locals? This is it, Oscar’s Grill! Halfway toward the island's South Point, you can find this top pick for locals and travelers alike! Best known for their large, filling and flavorsome pizzas, you can pick up, get delivery, or dine-in.

Sit along the main street, observing the bustling island life, with a slice of stuffed-crust pizza and a cold beer, as you sit at one of their large wooden tables. Or head downstairs, toward the backside of the restaurant for some harbor-side dining. If you’re going for a pizza, choose between a New York Style or Sicilian base, you can even get a stuffed crust of mozzarella cheese or Philadelphia cheese … and don’t forget to add-on their amazing garlic knots! As well as a great selection of pizzas, they also have pastas, seafood dishes, and of course, Mexican fare as well!